Chris' Outrageous Cheesecake Coconut cheesecake, custard, a chocolate layer, macaroon crust. The most maximalist slice in the case that doesn't have gelatin in it. Straight replacement for Oreo Dream Extreme.
contains cream cheese coconut custard chocolate macaroon egg wheat
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· no
+ -
Adam's Peanut Butter Cup Fudge Ripple Peanut butter, caramel, candy chunks, fudge swirl. Salt and fat doing the heavy lifting rather than sugar alone.
contains cream cheese peanut butter caramel chocolate wheat
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· no
+ -
Hershey's Chocolate Bar Cheesecake Cheesecake sandwiched in chocolate cake with chocolate frosting and chips. The clean chocolate play now that Godiva is off the table.
contains cream cheese chocolate chocolate cake wheat egg
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Toasted Marshmallow S'Mores Galore Torched marshmallow on top, graham and chocolate underneath. The only slice with a genuinely burnt, textural top edge.
contains cream cheese marshmallow chocolate graham cracker wheat
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Salted Caramel Cheesecake Caramel cheesecake and caramel mousse on a blondie base, salted on top. Currently one of their most-ordered flavors.
contains cream cheese caramel blondie base sea salt wheat
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Chocolate Hazelnut Crunch Cheesecake Hazelnut, chocolate, and a crunch layer. The crunch is what separates it from the other chocolate slices.
contains cream cheese hazelnut chocolate wheat
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· no
+ -
Chocolate Tuxedo Cream Cheesecake Alternating chocolate cake, cheesecake and chocolate mousse layers. Lighter on the palate than its height suggests.
contains cream cheese chocolate cake chocolate mousse wheat egg
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Reese's Peanut Butter Chocolate Cake Cheesecake Peanut butter cups suspended in cheesecake over fudge cake and caramel. Denser and sweeter than Adam's.
contains cream cheese peanut butter chocolate fudge cake caramel wheat
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· no
+ -
Chocolate Mousse Cheesecake Chocolate cheesecake under a Belgian chocolate mousse layer. The most texturally interesting of the pure-chocolate options.
contains cream cheese chocolate mousse wheat egg
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Graham crust, sour cream top. The baseline everything else is measured against, and gelatin-free.
contains cream cheese sour cream graham cracker wheat egg
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Original with Cherry Topping Same base, cherries on top. Acid cuts the richness.
contains cream cheese cherry graham cracker wheat egg
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Fresh Strawberry Cheesecake Their long-running bestseller. Glazed strawberries over the original.
contains cream cheese strawberry graham cracker wheat egg
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Ultimate Red Velvet Cake Cheesecake Red velvet layers with cream cheese frosting and white chocolate. Sweet, and a lot of it.
contains cream cheese red velvet cake white chocolate wheat egg
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Snickers Bar Chunks and Cheesecake Candy chunks swirled through cheesecake on a brownie crust. Reliable, not surprising.
contains cream cheese peanut caramel brownie nougat wheat
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· no
+ -
Caramel Pecan Turtle Cheesecake Caramel, pecans, chocolate. Nuts give it more structure than the average slice.
contains cream cheese pecan caramel chocolate wheat
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· no
+ -
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cheesecake Cookie dough folded in and frosted on top. Sweetest slice in the case by a distance.
contains cream cheese cookie dough chocolate chip wheat flour egg
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
White Chocolate Raspberry Truffle White chocolate and raspberry swirl. Tart enough to stay interesting.
contains cream cheese white chocolate raspberry wheat
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Lemon Meringue Cheesecake Torched meringue over lemon. The brightest thing in the case and the best pick after a heavy pasta order.
contains cream cheese lemon meringue egg wheat
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Lemon Raspberry Cream Cheesecake Lemon and raspberry layered together. Lighter finish.
contains cream cheese lemon raspberry wheat
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Coffee and cocoa treatment. Divisive — several published rankings put it near the bottom.
contains cream cheese coffee cocoa ladyfinger wheat egg
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Fresh Banana Cream Cheesecake Banana cheesecake with bavarian cream and sliced banana.
contains cream cheese banana bavarian cream wheat
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Craig's Crazy Carrot Cake Cheesecake Carrot cake and cheesecake alternating. Spice keeps it from reading as pure sugar.
contains cream cheese carrot cake cinnamon wheat flour egg
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Low carb, no added sugar, gluten-free crust. Exists if you want the ritual without the payload.
contains cream cheese gluten-free crust sweetener
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Chocolate Tower Truffle Cake Not a cheesecake — a stacked chocolate cake with truffle layers. If you want chocolate without the cream cheese tang, this is the order.
contains chocolate cake chocolate truffle wheat flour cream egg
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· no nut-free· unknown
+ -
Layered chocolate fudge cake. Simpler and less rich than the Tower.
contains chocolate cake fudge frosting wheat flour egg
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian vegan· no gluten-free· no dairy-free· unknown nut-free· unknown
+ -
Baked apples with a streusel top, ice cream alongside. The only dessert on the menu with a crisp, hot texture contrast.
contains apple ice cream streusel wheat flour oat
Italic = assumed, not printed on the menu.
vegetarian· unknown vegan· unknown gluten-free· no dairy-free· unknown nut-free· unknown
Crumble fat unconfirmed; may be lard rather than butter.
Confirm the crumble is butter-based, not lard — it's not on the published vegetarian list either way.
+ -